Honey Butter Three Ways

honey butter and fresh rolls

I created this recipe to please the meat eaters and the vegans in my life, and everyone in between. All versions of this recipe add a sweet, creamy lusciousness to whatever you choose to slather it on.

As a child, my family often made the trip from our home in the suburbs to the mountains of Virginia. If my brother and I were lucky, my parents would stop for a quick bite on the way. Our faaaavorite restaurant was an “all you can eat” Southern style buffet in a little town just off route 29. There was every manner of main course, side dish and dessert you could hope for. My brother and I ate it all, with reckless abandon.

I no longer feel the same way I did as a child about “all you can eat” or reckless abandon (when it comes to food). I have, however been back a few times for nostalgia’s sake.

My favorite combo was to get a big o’l puffy roll with a scoop of mashed potatoes, a helping of corn, gravy and top it all off with honey butter. In my subsequent visits, I discovered that the charm of this hodgepodge was through the lens of childhood. Only one thing held up to my mind’s eye…….you guessed it, the honey butter!

I tried to replicate the honey butter of my dreams, too no avail. This perplexed me. How could such a seemingly simple condiment be so hard to pin down?


A few years ago I was feeling uninspired and burnt out so I decided to peruse the internet for recipes to play with. As luck would have it, on this seemingly nondescript day, I came across a honey butter recipe from allrecipes.com. I almost bypassed it since my honey butter efforts had been meet with despair. Luckily I took a glance. Immediately I saw an ingredient that I had never tried before but appeared to be genius……sweetened condensed milk! Long story short, this was the missing link.

With a few adjustments, I transformed this recipe into the honey butter of my dreams. I also came up with a few variations on this traditional honey butter and all of them are seriously yummy! Honey butter makes otherwise ordinary dishes sing with flavor.


I’ve made a meaty version and a vegan version which I’m gonna share with you here, today. Pick your passion or make both, I think they’re equally tasty.

Another great thing about honey butter is that you can add additional flavorings for an even more gourmet treat. Some of my favorite additions are smoked paprika, bacon drippings, chili powder, cinnamon powder, vanilla and orange zest (not necessarily together or in that order). I encourage you to play around with flavor combinations that suit your fancy.

Honey butter is amazing with so many dishes. I like to add honey butter to mashed sweet potatoes or roasted root vegetables after baking. One of my favorite ways to enjoy honey butter is to combine it with warm, freshly popped popcorn. You end up with a treat reminiscent of kettle corn. For me, the pinnacle of the honey butter experience is to spread it over a hot, fresh from the oven, roll or biscuit.

Look at me wax poetic about honey butter for multiple paragraphs. Really though…….it’s that good!

clock clock iconcutlery cutlery iconflag flag iconfolder folder iconinstagram instagram iconpinterest pinterest iconfacebook facebook iconprint print iconsquares squares iconheart heart iconheart solid heart solid icon
honey butter and fresh rolls

Honey Butter Three Ways

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (3 votes, average: 5.00 out of 5)


  • Author: Asha
  • Total Time: 10 min
  • Yield: 1 bowl 1x


Units Scale

Master Recipe

  • 1 cup of Unsalted Butter, softened
  • 6 tablespoons Sweetened Condensed Milk
  • 6 tablespoons Honey (orange blossom, clover or wildflower)
  • 1/2 teaspoon sea salt
  • * optional, 2-3 tablespoons, reserved Bacon Drippings, cooled to room temperature
  • * optional, additional flavorings, adjust flavors to taste

Vegan Recipe

  • 1 cup of “vegan” style Butter (such as Earth Balance)
  • 6 tablespoons Sweetened Condensed Coconut Milk
  • 1/2 teaspoon sea salt
  • *optional, additional flavorings, adjust flavor to taste


  1. Bring all ingredients to room temperature.
  2. In the bowl of a stand mixer or in a medium bowl with a hand held mixer, whip all of the ingredients together until thoroughly combined and fluffy.
  3. Transfer to a clean, airtight container (such as a mason or ball jar) and store in the refrigerator.
  4. Set the honey butter out for a half hour or until it reaches room temperature, before serving.
  5. Enjoy liberally.


Keeps for up to a month in the refrigerator.

If the honey butter begins to separate, bring to room temperature and re-whip with a mixer or by hand.

Share This Recipe:

4 thoughts on “Honey Butter Three Ways”

  1. So glad to re-connect with you, Asha. I recall a gourmet Christmas dinner you created at your house several years ago. Todd and I were lucky guests. You are amazing!! Lynne in Pennsylvania


Leave a Comment

Hungry for more culinary inspiration? Subscribe to Kitchen Fairy!

We’re happy to send you recipes you’ll love every month. Don’t worry, we’ll never sell your information to a third party.

Subscribe for new posts:
Recent Posts
Popular Posts

Hot Chocolate Machica

More Recipes

cut of tuna ceviche

Tuna Ceviche

Quick, easy, elegant, and delicious. Ceviche is traditionally a Latin American dish of marinated raw fish or seafood. In this preparation, I put a spin on it by using only


Sobacha Tea Two Ways

Sobacha tea originates from east Asian cultures. Buckwheat groats are toasted then steeped to make a beautiful caramel colored tisane. Sobacha has a comforting nutty aroma and rich, malted, toasty flavor. As an avid drinker of all thing’s tea and tisane, I’m in love with sobacha and keep it on heavy rotation.


Powerhouse Hummus

If you’re reading this article, it’s safe to say you’re into hummus, and you’re probably intrigued by what could possibly turn quick, easy to make, standard hummus into a “powerhouse”


Shaved Fennel-Citrus Salad

This Shaved Fennel-Citrus Salad is bejeweled with juicy orange segments and adorned with feathery wisps of fennel fronds. Thin shavings of crisp anise flavored fennel are combined with delicate toothed leaves

Stay In Touch.

Subscribe for monthly culinary and hosting inspiration from Kitchen Fairy.